CELEBRATING MORE THAN YEARS
AWARDS & RECOGNITION
UPDATES
PRACTICE AREAS
PEOPLE
News and Articles
Sectoral FDI Caps
How Should Foreign Investors Assess Changes to India's Sectoral FDI Caps Before Signing a Share Purchase Agreement?
India’s Sectoral FDI Caps determine how much foreign investment an Indian business can receive in a particular sector, subject to applicable conditions. For foreign investors acquiring shares from an existing shareholder, a change in these limits can affect ownership rights, approval requirements, transaction timing and the value of the proposed investment. Reviewing the rules before signing a share purchase agreement is therefore essential. A proposed policy change does not always mean an investor can immediately acquire a larger stake. The effective date, implementing regulations, entry route, investor eligibility and sector specific conditions all matter. Investors should assess the rules in force, identify pending changes and structure the agreement to manage regulatory uncertainty before committing to completion. 1. Understand What a Sectoral FDI Cap Means A sectoral Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) cap is the maximum level of foreign investment permitted in an Indian entity carrying on a particular activity, subject to the relevant legal framework. The applicable limit may be 100%, a lower percentage or a restriction on foreign investment altogether. The cap is only one part of the analysis. Some sectors permit foreign investment under the automatic route, while others require prior government approval. Certain activities also impose licensing, security, ownership or operational conditions. For example, a foreign investor considering an acquisition in insurance, defence, telecommunications or financial services should not rely solely on a headline percentage reported in the news. The investor must identify the precise business activity and examine the conditions applicable to it. India's FDI framework is governed by the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (FEMA), the Foreign Exchange Management (Non Debt Instruments) Rules, 2019, the applicable FDI policy and related regulatory directions. These instruments must be read together to determine whether the proposed acquisition is permissible. The Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT) publishes policy announcements and amendments, while the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) administers relevant foreign exchange requirements. Investors should verify the applicable provisions through official sources rather than relying on summaries alone. 2. Identify Whether the Proposed Change Is Legally Effective One of the most important steps is distinguishing a government announcement from an operative legal amendment. A budget proposal, cabinet decision, press release or policy statement may indicate the government's intention to liberalise a sector. However, the transaction team must establish whether the relevant change has become legally effective and whether further conditions apply. Investors should examine the date of the announcement, the formal policy instrument, the corresponding amendment to the applicable rules and any commencement provisions. They should also check whether the change applies to transactions signed after a specified date, transactions completed after that date or only investments satisfying particular conditions. This distinction can materially affect a share purchase agreement. An investor may negotiate on the assumption of a higher foreign ownership limit, only to discover that the amendment is not yet effective or that the proposed transaction does not qualify for the revised treatment. The agreement should therefore identify the regulatory framework on which the parties are relying. If completion depends on a pending amendment, the parties should agree how they will respond if the amendment is delayed, modified or withdrawn. 3. Calculate Existing and Proposed Foreign Ownership Before signing, investors should calculate the target company's foreign investment position on a fully diluted basis where relevant. The review should consider existing foreign shareholdings, the proposed acquisition, convertible instruments and other interests included under the applicable rules. The calculation should not focus only on the percentage being purchased. The relevant question is whether the acquisition would cause total foreign investment to exceed the applicable cap or trigger a different approval route or regulatory condition. For example, suppose a company has an applicable foreign investment ceiling of 74% and existing foreign investors hold 68%. A proposed acquisition increasing foreign ownership by eight percentage points would take the total to 76%. Unless a valid legal basis permits the transaction under an applicable revised limit or other provision, the parties cannot assume the excess will be acceptable. Investors should also distinguish between direct ownership and indirect foreign investment. Where the structure includes Indian holding companies, overseas parent entities or multiple investment layers, the relevant rules may require a wider ownership analysis. A clear ownership chart should identify immediate shareholders, ultimate beneficial owners and any intermediate entities. It should also explain how the proposed transaction affects voting rights, control and any applicable sector specific ownership conditions. 4. Check Whether the Automatic or Government Route Applies A higher sectoral cap does not necessarily mean every foreign investor can invest freely. The entry route determines whether prior government approval is required, subject to the applicable policy and rules. Under the automatic route, prior government approval is generally not required for an otherwise permitted investment, although regulatory conditions and reporting obligations continue to apply. Under the government route, the investor must obtain the required approval before proceeding in accordance with its terms. The analysis should cover the target company's activities, the investor's identity and ownership, the proposed percentage and any relevant security or licensing conditions. Investors should also consider whether the transaction involves a change in ownership or control, since this can affect the regulatory analysis. Additional scrutiny may arise under the rules concerning investments from countries sharing a land border with India. The relevant restrictions can extend to certain beneficial ownership arrangements and subsequent changes in ownership. The precise position should be checked against the current rules and official guidance. Where approval is required, the parties should identify the responsible authorities, application requirements and likely impact on the transaction timetable. They should not treat an approval application as equivalent to approval being granted. 5. Assess the Effect on Valuation and Deal Economics Changes to Sectoral FDI Caps can influence a target company's investment appeal. Greater permitted foreign ownership may allow a buyer to acquire a larger stake, exercise additional influence or pursue a planned investment strategy. Yet the commercial benefit depends on the specific business and the conditions attached to the change. Investors should assess whether the proposed cap change affects the target's growth prospects, financing options, governance structure or potential exit opportunities. The analysis should also consider whether competitors can benefit from the same policy change and whether additional foreign capital may increase competition. Valuation should reflect the legal position at the time of the transaction, not simply the possibility of future liberalisation. If the purchase price assumes a higher cap or expanded ownership rights, the parties should explain how the assumption affects the agreed valuation. A buyer should also examine the pricing rules applicable to the transfer. Foreign investment regulations may impose specific pricing conditions for transfers between residents and non residents. A commercially agreed price must be assessed against those requirements where they apply. 6. Build Regulatory Protection Into the Share Purchase Agreement The share purchase agreement should allocate the risk of regulatory change and approval delays clearly. This is particularly important where the parties expect a sectoral cap to change between signing and completion. Conditions precedent may require the parties to obtain necessary approvals, secure regulatory confirmations or complete specified corporate actions before closing. The agreement should define which approvals are required and who is responsible for obtaining them. The parties should also consider a long stop date, which establishes the latest date for satisfying completion conditions. If approval is delayed beyond this date, the agreement should explain whether the parties can extend the deadline or terminate the transaction. Representations and warranties should address relevant matters such as the target's existing foreign ownership, regulatory compliance and accuracy of information supplied during due diligence. Appropriate indemnities may allocate responsibility for specified breaches or losses, although they cannot make an otherwise prohibited transaction lawful. Where the transaction depends on a pending policy change, the agreement should specify the consequences if the amendment does not take effect or its conditions differ from expectations. Any renegotiation mechanism should be clear enough to reduce the risk of a later dispute. 7. Review Reporting, Pricing and Completion Requirements Even where a transaction is permitted under the automatic route, foreign exchange reporting and other completion requirements may apply. The parties should identify the applicable forms, deadlines, supporting documents and responsibilities before signing. For a transfer of existing shares, the requirements can differ from those governing a fresh issue of shares. The parties should confirm the applicable process with the company's advisers and authorised dealer bank, particularly where the transaction involves cross border payment or a change in beneficial ownership. Investors should also verify any applicable sector regulator requirements, corporate approvals, contractual consents and licensing conditions. A transaction may satisfy the FDI cap but still face restrictions under another legal or regulatory framework. A practical compliance schedule can help the parties track each obligation from signing through completion and post completion reporting. It should identify the responsible party, the relevant deadline and the evidence required to demonstrate compliance. Businesses using FDI consulting services may find it helpful to coordinate legal, tax, valuation and regulatory workstreams before the agreement is finalised. The objective is to resolve material issues early rather than discover them after the purchase price and completion date have been agreed. 8. Monitor Policy Changes Between Signing and Completion A transaction may take weeks or months to complete. During this period, the applicable rules or government guidance may change. Investors should therefore review material regulatory developments between signing and closing, particularly when the transaction depends on a new sectoral cap or approval route. The agreement should specify how the parties will respond if a change affects the transaction's legality, economics or timing. Depending on the circumstances, the parties may need to obtain additional approval, amend the structure, revise the timetable or consider termination rights. Monitoring should include formal notifications and amendments, not merely media reports. The parties should also confirm whether a change has been incorporated into the relevant rules and whether any conditions apply to existing investments or pending transactions. Investors planning a wider Indian expansion should coordinate the acquisition with their long term corporate structure and compliance plans. Company setup services may be relevant where the transaction forms part of a broader establishment or restructuring strategy, but the choice of structure should follow the legal and commercial analysis rather than replace it.   Conclusion Foreign investors should assess Sectoral FDI Caps as part of a wider regulatory and commercial review before signing a share purchase agreement. The essential steps are to confirm the operative legal position, calculate existing and proposed foreign ownership, determine the correct entry route, assess valuation implications and document approval related risks. A carefully structured agreement can help manage uncertainty, but it cannot replace compliance with Indian law. Investors should verify the rules in force at signing and again before completion, especially when the transaction relies on a recent or proposed policy change Frequently Asked Questions What are Sectoral FDI Caps in India? Sectoral FDI Caps are the maximum foreign investment limits applicable to specified sectors or activities in India, subject to the relevant laws, entry routes and sector specific conditions. Can a foreign investor rely on a proposed increase in the FDI cap? Not without checking its legal status. The investor should verify the formal amendment, commencement date, implementing rules and any conditions governing the proposed change. Does a higher FDI cap remove the need for government approval? Not necessarily. The applicable entry route, investor eligibility, beneficial ownership and sector specific conditions must still be assessed. Some transactions may require prior government approval even where the cap permits the proposed percentage. How can a change in the FDI cap affect a share purchase agreement? It may affect ownership limits, approval conditions, valuation, completion timing and termination rights. The agreement should allocate the risk of delayed or unsuccessful regulatory approval. Do foreign investors need to review indirect ownership? Yes. The analysis may need to include intermediate entities, ultimate beneficial ownership and indirect foreign investment, depending on the applicable rules. Where can investors check India's latest FDI rules? Investors should consult official DPIIT policy announcements, the applicable Foreign Exchange Management (Non Debt Instruments) Rules and relevant RBI directions. Sector regulators may also publish additional requirements.
Existing Shareholder Purchase
What Should Foreign Investors Review Before Buying Shares From an Existing Indian Shareholder?
An Existing Shareholder Purchase can offer foreign investors a direct route into an established Indian business without requiring the company to issue new shares. However, buying shares from an existing shareholder involves more than agreeing on a price. Investors must verify ownership, assess the company’s financial and legal position, understand India’s foreign investment rules and confirm the transaction can be completed lawfully. A careful review also helps identify hidden liabilities, restrictions on share transfers and potential tax costs before funds change hands. Whether the target is a private limited company, an unlisted public company or a listed business, a structured due diligence process can protect the investment and reduce the risk of disputes after completion. 1. Verify the Seller’s Ownership and Right to Transfer Shares The first step is to establish whether the existing shareholder legally owns the shares and has the authority to sell them. A seller’s representation alone is insufficient. Investors should examine the company’s register of members, relevant share certificates, previous transfer records and available corporate filings. For dematerialised shares, the relevant depository records and account statements should also be reviewed. The investigation should establish the number and class of shares being sold, the seller’s beneficial ownership and any pledge, lien, charge or other third party interest affecting them. Where shares have passed through several owners, the transaction history should be checked for gaps or irregularities. Investors should also verify whether the seller is acting personally or on behalf of another entity. If a corporate shareholder is selling, its constitutional documents and internal approvals may be relevant. Where an attorney or authorised representative signs the documents, the authority to execute the transaction should be confirmed. These checks help establish whether the seller can deliver valid title and whether the buyer will receive the rights expected under the transaction. 2. Check Foreign Direct Investment Eligibility and Restrictions Foreign investors must assess the proposed acquisition under India’s foreign exchange framework before signing an unconditional purchase agreement. The Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (FEMA), the Foreign Exchange Management (Non Debt Instruments) Rules, 2019, the applicable Foreign Direct Investment policy and related regulatory directions govern many cross border share acquisitions. The first question is whether foreign investment is permitted in the target company’s business sector. Some sectors allow foreign investment under the automatic route, while others require prior government approval or impose specific conditions. Sectoral caps, licensing requirements and restrictions on the investor’s country of origin may also affect the transaction. A purchase from an existing shareholder is a transfer of ownership rather than a fresh issue of shares by the company. This distinction matters, but it does not remove the need to comply with foreign investment rules. The applicable pricing requirements, transfer conditions, reporting obligations and payment rules must be assessed for the particular transaction. Investors should also establish whether the acquisition changes the level of foreign ownership or control, or triggers conditions linked to government approval. Transactions involving regulated businesses may require additional scrutiny. The Reserve Bank of India’s Master Direction on Foreign Investment in India is an important starting point. The relevant rules and directions should be checked in their latest form before signing and completion. 3. Review the Company’s Articles and Shareholder Agreements Even when the seller is willing to transfer the shares, the company’s constitutional documents or existing contracts may restrict the proposed sale. This is particularly important for private limited companies, where the articles of association may contain transfer restrictions. Investors should review the articles of association, shareholders’ agreement, investment agreements and any other documents governing share ownership. These may provide existing shareholders with rights of first refusal, rights of first offer, pre emption rights or consent rights. The transaction may also require approval from the board, another shareholder or a lender. A transfer completed without observing an applicable contractual or constitutional restriction may lead to disputes, delays in registration or claims for remedies. The buyer should therefore establish which consents are required, who must provide them and when they must be obtained. The documents should also be checked for restrictions on voting, board representation, dividends, reserved matters and future transfers. These provisions can significantly affect the commercial value of the shares. Where the buyer expects management influence, it is important to distinguish between owning shares and having enforceable governance rights. A minority shareholding does not automatically provide control over business decisions. 4. Conduct Financial, Legal and Commercial Due Diligence An investor buying existing shares acquires an interest in the company as it stands, including its business risks and potential liabilities. Unlike a simple asset purchase, the acquisition does not automatically isolate the buyer from problems within the target company. Financial due diligence should examine audited accounts, management accounts, revenue quality, cash flow, debt, working capital and outstanding tax liabilities. Investors should identify related party transactions, unusual payments, contingent liabilities and significant differences between reported earnings and actual cash generation. Legal due diligence should cover material contracts, litigation, regulatory notices, licences, intellectual property, employment obligations and compliance with applicable laws. The review should also identify any outstanding loans, guarantees, security interests or contractual defaults. Commercial due diligence can help establish whether the business is sustainable. Customer concentration, supplier dependence, market position, technology risks and the strength of management may influence its future performance. For investors seeking to invest in small businesses, this review is especially important where formal record keeping is limited or financial information depends heavily on the founder. Missing documentation should not automatically end a transaction, but it should prompt further investigation and suitable contractual safeguards. The scope of due diligence should reflect the size, sector and complexity of the investment. Any material issue should be assessed for its likely financial impact and whether it can be resolved before completion. 5. Establish a Defensible Share Purchase Price A seller’s asking price may not reflect the company’s actual value or the rights attached to the shares. Investors should understand how the price has been calculated and whether the valuation accounts for debt, cash, future liabilities and the company’s financial performance. For an unlisted company, valuation may involve earnings, cash flow, comparable businesses, asset values or another suitable method. The chosen approach should reflect the company’s circumstances and the commercial basis of the transaction. Foreign investment rules may also prescribe pricing conditions for a transfer between a person resident in India and a person resident outside India. The applicable requirements depend on the parties’ residential status, the type of security, the transaction structure and other relevant facts. A commercial valuation should not be treated as automatically satisfying the regulatory pricing rules. Investors should confirm whether the purchase price is fixed or subject to adjustments for debt, working capital or other agreed items. The agreement should explain the treatment of any deferred consideration, escrow arrangements or indemnity retention. A clear valuation process reduces the risk of disputes and helps demonstrate why the agreed price is reasonable. It also supports regulatory and tax compliance where a valuation report is required. 6. Understand Tax Exposure and Transaction Costs Tax consequences should be assessed before the buyer and seller finalise the commercial terms. The seller may be liable for capital gains tax, depending on the nature of the shares, the holding period, the seller’s tax status and the applicable provisions. For a non resident seller, the analysis may involve Indian tax rules, treaty provisions where relevant, withholding obligations and procedural requirements. The parties should not assume a tax treaty eliminates Indian tax or removes the need to comply with domestic law. The buyer should separately consider withholding responsibilities, if applicable, and whether the agreed payment structure creates additional tax or reporting obligations. The tax position may differ for listed and unlisted shares and for transactions involving different categories of investors. Stamp duty and other transaction expenses should also be included in the completion budget. The applicable duty and transfer process can depend on how the shares are held and transferred. Tax rules can change, so investors should verify the provisions in force for the proposed transaction date. The Income Tax Department’s official guidance on the sale of shares is a useful starting point, but transaction specific advice may be needed. 7. Confirm Transfer Documents and Regulatory Reporting The parties should agree on the documents required to complete the transfer and ensure each step is properly recorded. Section 56 of the Companies Act, 2013 addresses the transfer and transmission of securities, subject to the applicable statutory framework and exceptions. For shares held in physical form, the prescribed transfer instrument, applicable stamping and supporting share documents may be required. Dematerialised shares generally follow the relevant depository process. The target company’s procedures and the parties’ legal status should be checked before completion. Foreign investment transactions may also require reporting through the relevant banking and regulatory channels. The precise requirements depend on the parties, the route of acquisition and the applicable rules. The investor should coordinate with the company, its authorised dealer bank and professional advisers to confirm deadlines, forms and supporting records. Completion should not be treated as finished merely because the purchase price has been paid. The buyer should verify the transfer has been properly recorded and the relevant ownership evidence is available. Any required post completion filings or notifications should be tracked to completion. 8. Negotiate Contractual Protection Before Signing A share purchase agreement should clearly set out the terms of the acquisition and the remedies available if the seller’s statements prove inaccurate or an agreed obligation is breached. The agreement should identify the shares, purchase price, payment arrangements, completion conditions and required consents. Seller warranties may address ownership, authority, encumbrances and disclosure of relevant information. Depending on the transaction, the buyer may also seek warranties or confirmations concerning the company’s financial position and material legal matters. Indemnities can allocate responsibility for specified losses, including identified tax claims or disclosed disputes. Their scope, duration, caps, exclusions and claims procedure should be negotiated carefully. A warranty is not a substitute for due diligence, and an indemnity is only as useful as its drafting and the seller’s ability to meet the obligation. The parties should also address confidentiality, access to information, termination rights and dispute resolution. If part of the purchase price is deferred, the agreement should explain the payment conditions and consequences of non payment or breach. For transactions involving significant sums, the buyer may consider escrow or another agreed mechanism to manage completion risks. The structure must remain consistent with applicable Indian law and foreign exchange requirements. 9. Assess Post Acquisition Rights and Future Exit Options Before completing the purchase, the investor should understand how the acquired shares fit into the company’s wider ownership structure. The percentage acquired may affect voting power, board appointment rights, dividend participation and the ability to influence important decisions. The buyer should check whether other shareholders have contractual rights capable of affecting future ownership changes. It should also consider whether the company’s articles and shareholder arrangements provide workable mechanisms for resolving deadlocks, transferring shares or exiting the investment. A foreign investor planning to register a new company may have greater flexibility over its initial governance arrangements. By contrast, a buyer entering an existing company must often work within established agreements and relationships. This makes careful review of existing rights particularly important. An exit plan should consider possible future buyers, transfer restrictions, regulatory pricing rules and the process for repatriating sale proceeds where relevant. The terms agreed at entry can influence how easily the investment may be sold later. Conclusion An Existing Shareholder Purchase can provide foreign investors with access to an established Indian business, but the transaction requires careful legal, financial, tax and regulatory review. Investors should verify ownership, confirm foreign investment eligibility, examine transfer restrictions, assess liabilities and establish a defensible purchase price before committing funds. A well drafted share purchase agreement, supported by appropriate due diligence and a clear completion process, can reduce avoidable risks and protect the investor’s commercial objectives. Since foreign investment rules and tax requirements may change, the transaction should be assessed against the law in force at the relevant time Frequently Asked Questions Can a foreign investor buy shares directly from an existing Indian shareholder? Yes, subject to the applicable foreign investment framework, sectoral restrictions, pricing conditions, transfer requirements and any necessary approvals. The precise conditions depend on the parties and the target company’s activities. Is government approval always required for a foreign investor to purchase existing shares? No. Some transactions may proceed under the automatic route, while others require government approval or must satisfy additional conditions. The sector, investor eligibility and transaction circumstances should be reviewed before signing. What documents should a foreign investor request before buying shares? Key documents may include the company’s constitutional documents, register of members, share certificates or depository records, shareholder agreements, financial statements, material contracts, tax records, litigation details and relevant regulatory approvals. The final list depends on the transaction. Who is responsible for tax on the sale of shares? The seller is generally responsible for tax on taxable gains, subject to the applicable law. The buyer may have withholding or other compliance responsibilities in certain circumstances. Both parties should obtain transaction specific tax advice. Can a share transfer be challenged after completion? Potentially. Disputes may arise from defective title, missing approvals, breaches of transfer restrictions, fraud or non compliance with applicable requirements. Proper due diligence, accurate documentation and valid completion procedures help reduce these risks. How long does an existing shareholder purchase take? There is no single timeframe. The duration depends on due diligence, negotiations, approvals, valuation, banking procedures and completion requirements. Transactions involving regulated sectors or complex ownership structures may take longer.
Joint Venture Defaults
How Can Overseas Businesses Protect Their Investment When an Indian Joint Venture Partner Defaults on Contractual Obligations?
Joint Venture Defaults can put an overseas investor’s capital, commercial relationships and long term plans at risk. An Indian joint venture partner may fail to contribute agreed funding, breach exclusivity obligations, withhold financial information, misuse intellectual property or make important decisions without the investor’s consent. If the parties cannot resolve the dispute promptly, the business may face operational disruption and a decline in value. The right response depends on the joint venture agreement, the company’s constitutional documents, the nature of the breach and the remedies available under Indian law. Overseas investors should act quickly, preserve evidence and review their contractual rights before taking steps such as suspending performance, seeking urgent relief or pursuing an exit. A carefully planned response can protect the investment while limiting avoidable commercial and legal risks. 1. Identify the Default and Review the Governing Documents The first step is to establish precisely what the Indian partner has failed to do. A missed capital contribution, an unauthorised transfer of shares and a breach of confidentiality may require very different responses. The investor should compare the partner’s conduct against the joint venture agreement, shareholders’ agreement, subscription documents, articles of association and any related commercial contracts. Review the relevant obligations, deadlines, notice requirements, cure periods and consequences of default. The documents may distinguish between an ordinary breach and a material default. They may also provide specific remedies, such as additional funding obligations, restrictions on voting, compulsory transfer mechanisms or termination rights. It is important to check whether the shareholders’ agreement is consistent with the company’s articles of association. A contractual right may be difficult to implement through the company if the necessary corporate provisions or approvals are missing. The legal effect of each provision depends on its wording, the parties involved and applicable law. The investor should also confirm which entity has suffered the loss. A breach of the joint venture agreement may give the investor a personal contractual claim, while harm suffered by the joint venture company may require action by the company or its authorised representatives. These claims should not be treated as interchangeable. 2. Preserve Evidence and Quantify the Loss Once a potential default is identified, preserve the evidence before relationships deteriorate further. Relevant records may include signed agreements, board minutes, emails, payment records, financial statements, bank confirmations, management reports and correspondence about the disputed obligation. Prepare a chronology of events showing what was required, when performance was due, what occurred and how the breach affected the business. Record the financial consequences where possible. These may include unpaid contributions, additional borrowing costs, lost revenue, contractual penalties or expenses incurred to prevent operational disruption. The investor should avoid altering records or making unsupported allegations. Communications should remain factual and consistent with the company’s confidentiality obligations. If there is a risk of evidence being destroyed or assets being transferred, obtain urgent advice about lawful preservation measures and available interim relief. Financial analysis is equally important. An investor should distinguish between losses directly caused by the breach and losses arising from wider market or operational conditions. A clear calculation helps assess the commercial value of a claim and supports settlement discussions or formal proceedings. 3. Serve a Contractual Notice and Consider a Cure Period Many joint venture agreements require a written default notice before certain remedies can be exercised. The notice may need to describe the breach, identify the relevant contractual provision, specify the action required and allow a defined period for correction. Follow the agreement’s notice clause carefully. Check the permitted delivery method, recipient, address and timing rules. A notice sent informally to the wrong person or through an unauthorised channel may create avoidable disputes about whether the contractual process was followed. Where a cure period applies, assess whether the breach can realistically be remedied. A missed payment may be corrected by transferring funds, while misuse of confidential information or an unauthorised competing business may require more complex steps. If the partner proposes a solution, document the terms and any agreed extension. Do not assume every breach permits immediate termination or suspension of performance. Taking action without a contractual or legal basis can expose the investor to a counterclaim. Before exercising a remedy, assess whether the breach meets the relevant threshold and whether additional approvals or notices are required. 4. Enforce Shareholder and Governance Rights A partner’s default may involve more than a failure to pay or perform. It may also affect board control, access to information, reserved matters or the investor’s ability to participate in decisions. Review the governance provisions in the shareholders’ agreement and the company’s articles. These may address board appointment rights, quorum requirements, information access, approval thresholds, related party transactions and decisions requiring investor consent. If the Indian partner has approved a transaction without the required consent, examine the validity of the decision and the available remedies. Maintain a record of requests for financial information, board papers and statutory records. Where the company is failing to comply with its legal obligations, determine whether a shareholder, director or the company itself has the appropriate right to take action. In certain circumstances, conduct involving oppression of members or prejudice to the company may justify proceedings under Sections 241 and 242 of the Companies Act, 2013, subject to the statutory requirements and eligibility rules. These provisions are not a general remedy for every contractual disagreement. The facts must support the relevant legal grounds. The official text of the Companies Act, 2013 provides the statutory framework for company governance and shareholder remedies in India. 5. Consider Arbitration, Litigation and Urgent Interim Relief Many cross border joint venture agreements contain arbitration clauses. These may specify the seat of arbitration, applicable rules, number of arbitrators, language and governing law. Each element matters, particularly when the investor and the Indian partner are based in different jurisdictions. Before commencing proceedings, check whether the dispute falls within the arbitration clause and whether the agreement requires negotiation or mediation first. The investor should also assess the likely costs, duration, available remedies and location of assets against which an award may need to be enforced. Where urgent protection is required, interim relief may be available. Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 allows a party to apply to an appropriate court for certain interim measures in support of arbitration. Depending on the circumstances, relief may concern preservation of property, securing the amount in dispute, injunctions or appointment of a receiver. Once a tribunal is constituted, Section 17 and the statutory limits on court intervention must also be considered. An application is not automatically granted merely because a breach is alleged. The investor must establish the relevant legal basis and satisfy the applicable requirements for interim protection. Urgent advice is especially important where assets may be dissipated, confidential information may be disclosed or a disputed transaction may be completed before the dispute is resolved. 6. Assess Damages, Specific Performance and Other Remedies The appropriate remedy depends on the nature of the obligation and the terms of the agreement. A claim for damages may be suitable where the investor can establish a contractual breach and recoverable loss. The amount may depend on causation, evidence, contractual limitations and applicable legal principles. In some cases, the investor may seek performance of a contractual obligation or an injunction to prevent a threatened breach. The Specific Relief Act, 1963 governs important aspects of specific performance and related relief, but not every contractual obligation can be enforced in the same way. The court will consider the applicable statutory requirements and circumstances. A joint venture agreement may also contain liquidated damages provisions, indemnities, limitation of liability clauses and exclusions of certain losses. Their effect should be assessed under the governing law and the facts. A stated sum in a contract should not be assumed to be automatically recoverable in full. The investor should also assess enforceability before pursuing a claim. A favourable judgment or arbitral award is of limited practical value if the defaulting party has no accessible assets. Early asset and solvency analysis can help determine whether interim protection, negotiated security or another strategy is appropriate. 7. Evaluate Exit Rights and Share Transfer Restrictions Where trust has broken down, continuing the joint venture may no longer be commercially viable. The investor should examine whether the agreement provides a put option, call option, buyout mechanism, right of first refusal, tag along right, drag along right or exit following a specified default. The wording and conditions of these rights require careful review. A compulsory share transfer may depend on a defined trigger, valuation mechanism, notice period or independent expert determination. The company’s articles and applicable corporate law should also be checked to establish whether the proposed transfer can be implemented. Foreign investment rules are particularly important where shares in an Indian company are transferred between a non resident and a resident, or between non residents in circumstances covered by the relevant framework. Pricing requirements, sectoral conditions, eligibility rules, tax consequences and reporting obligations may apply. The Reserve Bank of India’s Master Direction on Foreign Investment in India is a key starting point for reviewing the foreign exchange framework, alongside the current legislation and rules. An exit should therefore be planned as a legal and financial transaction, not simply as a contractual demand. Independent valuation, tax advice, regulatory review and an assessment of the company’s solvency may all be necessary. 8. Use Negotiation and Restructuring Where Commercially Viable Formal proceedings are not always the best first outcome. If the joint venture remains valuable, the parties may be able to agree on a remedial plan. Options include a revised funding timetable, additional security, changes to management responsibilities, stronger reporting requirements or an agreed buyout. Any settlement should identify the obligations being corrected, deadlines, consequences of further default and treatment of existing claims. It should also state whether the parties are releasing particular claims or preserving their rights if the settlement fails. For overseas businesses considering business investment protection, the experience of a partner default should inform future transaction design. Stronger governance rights, clear default definitions, realistic cure periods, dispute resolution provisions and workable exit mechanisms can reduce uncertainty before capital is committed. 9. Prevent Future Defaults Through Better Joint Venture Planning Preventive measures begin during due diligence and contract negotiation. Investors should assess the Indian partner’s financial position, litigation history, regulatory compliance, management capability and track record of meeting commercial commitments. The joint venture agreement should set out funding obligations, responsibilities, performance standards, reporting requirements and consequences of non compliance. It should also address deadlock, confidentiality, intellectual property, related party dealings, changes in control and the circumstances in which a party may exit. The company’s constitutional documents should support the intended governance arrangements. If the parties are setting up a new company, they should align the shareholders’ agreement, articles of association and initial corporate approvals from the beginning. This reduces the risk of discovering later that an important contractual protection is difficult to implement through the company. Regular monitoring is equally important. Review financial performance, capital requirements, compliance records and board decisions at agreed intervals. Early warning indicators can give the investor an opportunity to address problems before they become material defaults.   Conclusion When an Indian joint venture partner defaults, an overseas investor should identify the breach, preserve evidence, follow contractual notice procedures and assess the available remedies before taking decisive action. Governance rights, arbitration, interim protection, damages and exit mechanisms may each play a role, depending on the facts. The most effective strategy combines legal analysis with commercial judgement. Investors should consider the enforceability of their rights, the financial condition of the joint venture and the practical prospects of recovery. Strong agreements, careful due diligence and ongoing monitoring remain the best foundations for protecting an overseas investment Frequently Asked Questions What counts as a joint venture default in India? A default occurs when a party fails to meet an obligation under the joint venture agreement or another relevant contract. Examples include failing to contribute agreed capital, breaching exclusivity, withholding required information or making decisions without necessary consent. The consequences depend on the contract and applicable law. Can a foreign investor take legal action against an Indian joint venture partner? Yes, where a valid legal claim exists. The available route may involve negotiation, arbitration or court proceedings, depending on the agreement and the nature of the dispute. The investor should check jurisdiction, limitation periods and any contractual preconditions before commencing action. Can an investor freeze the Indian partner’s assets? An investor cannot freeze assets simply by alleging default. It may apply for appropriate interim relief where the legal requirements are satisfied. The court or tribunal will assess the facts, the relief sought and the applicable legal standards. Can a joint venture agreement be terminated after a breach? Termination may be available where the agreement or applicable law permits it and any required notice or cure procedure has been followed. A material breach does not automatically give every party an unrestricted right to terminate. The contract and circumstances should be reviewed before action is taken. Can a foreign investor force the Indian partner to buy its shares? A buyout may be possible if the contract provides an enforceable mechanism or another legal basis exists. The investor must review the trigger conditions, valuation provisions, corporate documents and applicable foreign investment rules. A contractual exit right does not remove relevant regulatory requirements. Is arbitration better than litigation for a joint venture dispute? Neither route is universally better. Arbitration may offer procedural flexibility and a neutral forum for a cross border dispute, while court proceedings may be needed for certain forms of relief or issues outside the arbitration agreement. The appropriate route depends on the contract, urgency, costs, enforceability and assets involved.
Investment IP Protection
How Can a Foreign Investor Protect Intellectual Property When Investing in an Indian Technology Company?
Investment IP Protection is a central consideration for foreign investors evaluating an Indian technology company. Software, patents, algorithms, brands, product designs, proprietary data and confidential business methods can account for a substantial part of a technology business’s value. Yet investors may discover during due diligence that important intellectual property (IP) is registered in a founder’s name, developed by a contractor, licensed from a third party or insufficiently protected. A strong protection strategy starts before the investment closes. It combines legal due diligence, clear ownership records, appropriate registrations, carefully drafted investment documents and practical safeguards for confidential information. Foreign investors should also consider how Indian law applies to the specific IP rights involved, since protection and enforcement differ between patents, copyright, trade marks and trade secrets. 1. Conduct Thorough Intellectual Property Due Diligence Before investing, examine the company’s IP portfolio and establish whether it owns or has valid rights to use the assets central to its business. Request a detailed IP register covering registered rights, pending applications, software, source code, product designs, domain names, trade secrets, licences and material third party technology. The review should identify the legal owner of each asset, the date and circumstances of creation, relevant registration details, renewal dates, territorial coverage and any restrictions on use or transfer. Search relevant official IP records for applications, registrations, ownership details and potential conflicts. Check for disputes, opposition proceedings, infringement allegations, security interests and previous assignments. Ownership deserves particular attention. A company may use software developed by its founders before incorporation, or rely on code created by freelancers without a properly documented assignment. Employment alone should not be treated as conclusive proof of ownership for every category of IP. Review the applicable contracts and statutory rules, then obtain additional assignments or permissions where needed. Investors should also distinguish between ownership and permission to use. A technology company may lawfully use a third party’s software under a licence, but the licence may restrict sublicensing, modification, commercial use or a change of control. These limitations can affect the business’s valuation and future expansion. 2. Confirm Ownership of Software, Inventions and Other IP Investment agreements should not rely on broad statements about IP ownership without checking the underlying chain of title. The company should be able to demonstrate how important assets passed from their creators to the business. For software, review agreements with founders, employees, consultants, agencies and outsourced development teams. Confirm whether the relevant rights have been assigned in writing, whether the assignment covers the necessary forms of exploitation and whether it addresses future modifications. Where source code, technical documentation or product designs were created outside India, consider the laws and agreements relevant to those jurisdictions as well. The Indian Copyright Act, 1957 governs copyright protection for qualifying works, including computer programmes. Copyright and ownership are related but distinct questions: the existence of copyright does not automatically establish that the investing company owns the rights. Written documentation is therefore important, particularly where a business depends on software built by several contributors. For inventions, examine patent applications and granted patents, inventorship, applicant details, prosecution history, renewal payments and any licences or encumbrances. Verify whether the company’s commercial product falls within the protection claimed by the patent; a patent’s existence does not necessarily establish freedom to operate against other parties’ rights. The official Indian Patent Office guidance explains the principal requirements for patent protection in India, including novelty, inventive step and industrial applicability. Investors should obtain specialist review where patent validity, infringement risk or ownership could materially affect the investment. 3. Register and Maintain the Right Types of IP Protection Not every technology asset should be protected in the same way. A patent may be appropriate for a qualifying invention, while copyright may protect original software code and documentation. Trade marks can protect distinctive names and logos used to identify products or services. Registered designs may protect qualifying visual features of products. Investors should assess whether key registrations exist in India and in other markets where the company operates or plans to expand. A registration in one country does not automatically create equivalent protection worldwide. International filing strategies should reflect the business’s target markets, budget, disclosure risks and commercial priorities. Check application status, renewal obligations, ownership records and the scope of each right. If a trade mark or patent is held by a founder or an affiliated company, determine whether it should be assigned to the operating company or licensed under a carefully defined agreement. The chosen structure should fit the investment, tax, financing and operational arrangements. Registration is only one part of the strategy. Investors should also confirm who is responsible for renewals, responding to objections, monitoring infringement and maintaining accurate records. Missing a deadline or failing to document an assignment can weaken the commercial value of an otherwise useful IP portfolio. 4. Protect Trade Secrets and Confidential Information Some of a technology company’s most valuable assets may not be registered at all. These can include source code, model parameters, manufacturing methods, pricing strategies, customer lists, product roadmaps and technical know how. Public disclosure may reduce their competitive value and, for patentable inventions, may also affect patentability. India does not have a single comprehensive statute dedicated exclusively to trade secrets. Confidential information is protected through a combination of contractual arrangements and applicable legal principles. Consequently, a company should be able to demonstrate both that information is confidential and that reasonable steps have been taken to keep it confidential. Review non disclosure agreements, employment contracts, contractor terms and collaboration agreements. Check whether access is limited to people who need the information, whether repositories are secured, and whether confidential material is marked, monitored and handled under clear policies. A confidentiality clause should define the protected information, permitted use, authorised disclosure and obligations following termination, subject to applicable law. Investors should also review exit procedures. Departing employees and contractors should return devices and documents, surrender access credentials and comply with continuing confidentiality obligations. These measures cannot eliminate every risk, but they make unauthorised use easier to detect and address. 5. Review Open Source Software and Third Party Licences Technology businesses often build products using open source components, software development kits, cloud services, application programming interfaces and licensed datasets. These tools can reduce development costs, but their licence conditions may affect distribution, modification, attribution, disclosure and commercialisation. Request a software bill of materials or an equivalent inventory where appropriate. Identify important components and review their licences, including any obligations triggered by distributing or modifying software. Particular care is warranted where a licence may require source code disclosure or impose conditions incompatible with the company’s intended commercial model. Check whether the business has complied with attribution, notice, source availability and other applicable licence obligations. Review cloud, data and technology agreements for termination rights, usage limits, audit rights and change of control provisions. A licence breach or dependency on a supplier with weak continuity protections can create operational and valuation risks. The aim is not to avoid all third party technology. It is to understand the terms under which the company may continue using it after the investment and to address material risks before completion. 6. Include Strong IP Protections in Investment Agreements Investment documentation should convert due diligence findings into enforceable obligations and practical remedies. The share subscription agreement, shareholders’ agreement and related transaction documents should address IP ownership, disclosure, use and future development in a way that reflects the company’s actual business. The investor should consider representations and warranties confirming the company’s ownership of, or valid rights to use, material IP. These may cover the accuracy of the IP register, the disclosure of third party licences, the absence of undisclosed disputes and the execution of relevant employee and contractor agreements. Warranties should be carefully negotiated and supported by evidence rather than treated as a substitute for due diligence. Where a material ownership gap or licence issue is identified, the investor may require corrective action before completion. Depending on the circumstances, this could include obtaining an assignment, securing a necessary consent, recording a transfer, resolving a dispute or completing a registration. Indemnities may allocate financial responsibility for specified IP risks, subject to negotiated limits, exclusions and time periods. The agreement should also address future developments. If the company will create new software, inventions or designs after the investment, its employment and contractor arrangements should specify how relevant rights will be owned or licensed. Investors should review reserved matters and information rights where appropriate, so significant IP transfers, exclusive licences or disposals receive suitable governance oversight. 7. Establish Clear Founder, Employee and Contractor Obligations People are often the source of a technology company’s most valuable intellectual property. Investors should therefore review how the business manages IP created by founders, employees, consultants and outsourced developers. Employment and consultancy agreements should clearly address ownership of work created for the business, confidentiality, permitted use of company resources and disclosure of relevant inventions. The language must fit the applicable law and the type of IP involved. Where additional assignments are required, they should be properly executed rather than left as a post investment administrative task. The company should also check whether developers have used prior employer materials, third party code or personal projects in its products. A founder’s assurance may be useful, but it should not replace a review of relevant records where material risks exist. For foreign investors seeking to invest in startups, IP review should be integrated into commercial and financial due diligence from the outset. A promising product may still carry substantial legal risk if the company cannot demonstrate clear rights to its core technology. 8. Address Cross Border Licensing and Data Protection Foreign investors sometimes plan to share technology between an Indian company and an overseas parent, group company or research partner. Before transferring or licensing IP across borders, identify the parties’ respective rights, the permitted purpose, territory, duration, sublicensing rights, quality controls and termination consequences. The agreement should distinguish ownership of pre existing IP from ownership of improvements developed through collaboration. It should also address access to source code, technical support, derivative works and rights to continue using technology if the commercial relationship ends. Where the arrangement involves payments between related entities, obtain advice on applicable tax, transfer pricing and foreign exchange requirements. Data needs separate analysis. Customer information, employee records and datasets used to train or operate technology products may be subject to privacy, contractual, sector specific and cybersecurity obligations. A company’s access to data does not automatically mean it owns the data or may use it for every purpose. Investors should examine data collection notices, consent or other applicable legal grounds, retention practices, security controls, vendor arrangements and cross border access. India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 and its applicable rules and commencement provisions should be assessed for the particular transaction and operational model. Personal data, confidential business information and intellectual property are distinct legal categories, even when they overlap. 9. Build an Ongoing IP Management and Enforcement Plan IP protection should continue after the investment closes. The company needs a clear process for maintaining registrations, documenting new developments, reviewing licences, controlling confidential information and responding to suspected infringement. Assign responsibility for each material IP asset. Maintain a central register of ownership, applications, renewals, licences, restrictions and relevant agreements. Establish procedures for approving public disclosures of potentially patentable inventions and for checking third party rights before launching new products in important markets. The investor should also understand the company’s enforcement options. Depending on the right and circumstances, these may include negotiations, cease and desist notices, contractual remedies, opposition or cancellation proceedings, and court action. Enforcement can be costly, so the business should assess the commercial value of the right, the evidence available and the likely impact on operations before deciding on a course of action. Where a new Indian entity is being established as part of the transaction, new company formation should be coordinated with IP ownership planning. Founders and group companies should decide early whether core technology will be owned by the Indian operating company or licensed to it by another group entity. The arrangement should be documented, commercially workable and reviewed for applicable tax, regulatory and funding implications. 10. A Practical Pre Investment IP Checklist Before committing funds, a foreign investor should be able to answer five central questions. Does the company own or have valid rights to use the IP required for its business? Are registrations, assignments and licences documented and current? Are trade secrets protected through effective contractual and technical controls? Can the company lawfully use its software, datasets and third party technology under the relevant terms? Do the investment documents allocate material IP risks and provide a workable process for future developments? The answers should be recorded in the due diligence findings, with each significant issue assigned an owner, a deadline and an agreed remedy. High risk issues may need to be resolved before completion, while lower risk matters may be addressed through post completion undertakings and monitoring. The appropriate approach depends on the importance of the asset, the likelihood of a claim and the investor’s negotiating position. Conclusion Foreign investors can reduce intellectual property risk by combining thorough due diligence with clear ownership records, appropriate registrations, strong confidentiality controls and carefully negotiated investment documents. Particular attention should be given to founder developed technology, employee and contractor contributions, open source software, third party licences and cross border arrangements. The objective is not simply to collect a list of patents or trade marks. It is to establish whether the technology company has the legal rights, documentation and practical controls needed to protect and commercialise its core assets. A tailored IP review before investment, followed by ongoing governance and compliance, helps preserve the value of the investment and reduces avoidable disputes Frequently Asked Questions 1. Can a foreign investor own intellectual property in India? Yes. Foreign individuals and entities can generally own eligible IP rights in India, subject to the requirements of the relevant legislation and applicable restrictions. The investor should ensure ownership or licensing arrangements are properly documented and any relevant registrations are maintained. 2. Is software automatically protected by copyright in India? Original software may qualify for copyright protection under the Copyright Act, 1957. However, copyright protection does not by itself prove the investing company owns the software. Contracts, authorship, assignments and third party contributions must be reviewed. 3. Are trade secrets protected under Indian law? Confidential business information may be protected through contractual obligations and applicable legal principles. Companies should use appropriate confidentiality agreements and practical security controls. Unlike registered patents or trade marks, trade secret protection depends heavily on maintaining secrecy. 4. Should IP due diligence take place before an investment? Yes. Pre investment review helps identify ownership gaps, licence restrictions, infringement risks and missing registrations before the investor commits funds. Material issues can then be addressed through corrective action, transaction conditions or negotiated contractual protections. 5. What should an investor do if a founder personally owns the company’s technology? The investor should establish the founder’s legal rights and assess whether an assignment or licence is needed. The arrangement should define the scope of rights, permitted use and any continuing obligations. The transaction should not assume the company owns the technology merely because it uses it. 6. Can an Indian technology company transfer IP to an overseas parent company? A transfer or licence may be possible, but it requires careful review of ownership, contractual restrictions, applicable tax and transfer pricing rules, and any relevant foreign exchange or sector specific requirements. The structure should be assessed before the transaction is implemented.
MHCO Updates
Supreme Court
SUPREME COURT HOLDS YES BANK ADMINISTRATOR LACKED AUTHORITY TO WRITE OFF RS. 8,415 CRORE AT-1 BONDS
In Yes Bank Limited & Anr. v. Axis Trustee Services Limited & Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 3182 of 2025 and connected matters, judgment dated 15 October 2026), the Supreme Court dismissed the appeals and upheld the Bombay High Court’s decision setting aside the write-down of Yes Bank’s Basel III-compliant Additional Tier 1 (“AT-1”) Bonds. The Court held that the Administrator could not write down the bonds contrary to the final Reconstruction Scheme or exercise a regulatory power vested in the Reserve Bank of India (“RBI”). BACKGROUND Yes Bank issued AT-1 Bonds worth Rs. 3,000 crores in December 2016 and Rs. 5,415 crore in October 2017. Following a steep deterioration in Yes Bank’s financial position, the Central Government imposed a moratorium on 5 March 2020, and the RBI appointed an Administrator. A draft reconstruction scheme published on 6 March 2020 expressly provided for the AT-1 Bonds to be permanently written down in full. However, the final Yes Bank Limited Reconstruction Scheme, notified on 13 March 2020, omitted that clause. On 14 March 2020, the Administrator nevertheless ordered a full write-down of the Rs. 8,415 crore AT-1 Bonds. Therefore, the trustee and bondholders challenged the action, and the Bombay High Court set it aside. CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES The appellants, including Yes Bank, the RBI and the Union of India, contended that the Administrator was empowered under Section 36ACA of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (“Banking Regulation Act”), the RBI’s Master Circular on Basel III Capital Regulations and the Information Memorandum to write down the bonds. They argued that invocation of Section 45 of the Banking Regulation Act triggered the point of non-viability and that the write-down, followed by SBI’s infusion of capital, was necessary to revive Yes Bank. They also argued that the reconstruction process continued after notification of the Scheme. The respondents contended that the final Reconstruction Scheme deliberately omitted the draft provision for writing down the bonds. They argued that the Administrator could not write down the bonds after the Scheme came into force and that, under the Master Circular, the relevant action had to be taken before reconstruction. They further submitted that the power to determine the write-down at the point of non-viability belonged to the RBI, not the Administrator. COURT’S FINDINGS The Court held that the omission of the write-down clause from the final Reconstruction Scheme reflected a conscious decision not to deal with the bonds through the Scheme. The Administrator could not reverse that decision. A general clause preserving existing instruments did not confer a specific power to write down the bonds; the action was therefore ultra vires the Master Circular read with the Reconstruction Scheme. The Court further held that the phrase “before reconstitution” in the Master Circular meant before the Reconstruction Scheme came into force, and not at any time while the Scheme’s effects continued. Once the point of non-viability was triggered, the RBI was required to determine the treatment of the bonds. The Administrator, whose statutory role was to act as a substitute for the Board of Directors, could not assume the RBI’s regulatory power. The Court observed that financial necessity could not excuse non-compliance with the prescribed procedure. It accordingly dismissed the appeals and clarified that its observations would not influence other pending proceedings. MHCO COMMENT The judgment reinforces that regulatory and administrative powers must be exercised strictly within the limits prescribed by statute and the applicable regulatory framework. The commercial necessity of rescuing a bank cannot override the authority, timing and procedure mandated by law. The decision is also significant for the distinction it draws between the Administrator’s powers as a substitute for the Board of Directors and the RBI’s independent regulatory powers. The Administrator cannot assume a function specifically entrusted to the RBI. Further, a general provision preserving existing contracts cannot be used to imply a specific power that the final Reconstruction Scheme has omitted. For market participants and financial institutions, the judgment highlights the importance of consistency between a reconstruction scheme, the RBI’s capital regulations and the terms of the relevant bond documentation. It also draws attention to investor-protection concerns surrounding the sale of complex, high-risk capital instruments to retail investors. Date: 19 October 2026 By: Mr.  Bhushan Shah, Partner Ms. Sayali Kshirsagar, Associate Mr. Abhishek Nair, Associate Disclaimer: This legal update is intended for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers are advised to seek specific legal advice before acting upon any information contained herein.
Litigation
LITIGATION UPDATE | SUPREME COURT UPHOLDS OCCUPANTS' RIGHTS IN REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS, REINSTATES MHADA ORDERS FOR PERMANENT ALTERNATE ACCOMMODATION
Overview: The Supreme Court of India, vide its judgment dated July 23, 2026, in Mahabanoo Contractor and Another v. Kalikund Developers and Others (Civil Appeal No. 9342 of 2026), set aside a Bombay High Court decision and ruled in favour of the occupants of a redeveloped cessed building. The Supreme Court upheld the Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority’s (MHADA) orders directing the developer to execute the Permanent Alternate Accommodation Agreement (PAAA) and hand over possession. The ruling firmly establishes that a PAAA executed under the Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Act, 1976 (MHAD Act) and the Development Control (DC) Regulations is not merely a private arrangement but is governed by a statutory scheme protecting occupants' rights. Brief Background and Facts: The dispute arose regarding a cessed building unfit for human habitation, which the developer (Respondent No. 1) undertook to demolish and redevelop under the MHAD Act, obtaining a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from MHADA. Occupants vacated the premises on the assurance of alternate accommodation in the reconstructed building. The first Appellant and the late Ms. Gool Peshotan Unwalla were joint occupants of Room No. 5 on the third floor of the old building. Following the redevelopment, the developer refused to honour the PAAA executed on 17 October 2019, which granted the Appellants three flats (inclusive of fungible area) totalling 309.98 sq. mtrs. Instead, the developer offered a smaller area, contending that the fungible Floor Space Index (FSI) was not fully utilized due to a reduction in the building's height from 34 to 30 floors. Upon the Appellants' complaint, MHADA issued orders on 28 May 2025, and 27 June 2025, directing the developer to register the PAAA and hand over possession, which were followed by a Show Cause Notice on 10 July 2025 when the developer failed to comply with the orders. The developer challenged the orders and the Show Cause Notice in the Bombay High Court, which stayed MHADA's actions by classifying the PAAA as a "private arrangement" amenable only to civil court jurisdiction. The Hon’ble High Court recorded the developer's undertaking to keep two flats encumbrance-free until a civil suit was decided. Subsequently, the developer filed a civil suit challenging the validity of the PAAA in its entirety. Contentions of the Parties: The Appellants (Occupants): The Appellants emphasized the statutory definition of 'occupant' under the MHAD Act and Rule 33(7) of the DC Regulations. They argued that the PAAA was a statutory requirement enforced by MHADA, not a private arrangement. They further relied on contemporaneous public notices, the certified list of tenants by MHADA, and the developer's NOC, all of which documented the first Appellant as a rightful joint occupant. The Respondents (Developer): The Respondents contended that the PAAA was a concocted document executed by a former expelled partner without proper authorization. They argued that upon the original tenant's death, the tenancy was extinguished, leaving the Appellants without rights to the premises. Furthermore, they asserted the carpet area allotted in the PAAA was excessive compared to the original tenement's area, especially considering that the FSI was not fully utilised. Court’s Findings: The Division Bench of the Supreme Court consisting of the Hon’ble Justice Shri J.B. Pardiwala and the Hon’ble Justice K. Vinod Chandran made several key observations: Statutory Nature of the PAAA: The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the High Court had misconstrued the PAAA as a mere private arrangement. It was held that the PAAA was executed under the MHAD Act, which is a statutory scheme, and was meant to facilitate redevelopment while ensuring that the original occupants were not displaced. Its enforcement therefore fell squarely within MHADA's regulatory purview. Definition of 'Occupant': The Hon’ble Court held that the MHAD Act defines "occupier" under Section 2(25) as encompassing more than just the statutory tenants. It was held that the first Appellant’s status as an occupant was firmly established by multiple contemporaneous documents, including the developer's own 2010 public notice and MHADA's certified list. Developer's Conduct and Internal Disputes: The Hon’ble Court rejected the developer's attempt to use internal partnership disputes to invalidate agreements made with the occupants, stating that the occupants were not even made a party to the consent terms executed between the partners. It was held that the settlement of inter-se disputes between partners cannot absolve the developer from obligations under a validly executed PAAA, on the basis of which vacant possession was originally obtained. Additionally, it was held that the developer's failure to utilize the full fungible area does not justify resiling from the agreed allotments. Mala Fide Civil Suit: The Hon’ble Court found the civil suit filed by the developer to be misconceived and mala fide in nature because it sought to challenge the Appellants' very claim as occupants contrary to the undertaking given by the developer to the High Court. Judgment: The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the Bombay High Court's judgment and reviving MHADA’s original orders. The Hon’ble Court directed the developers to execute the PAAA and hand over possession of the three apartments within two months and stated that if they failed to do so, the Appellants were entitled to recover damages calculated at the monthly rental value of the flats. The Hon’ble Court further restrained the High Court from proceeding with the developer's civil suit and imposed heavy costs on the developer. MHCO Comment: This pivotal judgment strictly curtails the dilatory tactics often employed by developers in redevelopment schemes to avoid handing over agreed-upon permanent alternate accommodations. By reiterating that the PAAA is a statutory instrument governed by the MHAD Act, rather than a standard private contract, the Supreme Court has fortified the regulatory authority of bodies like MHADA to intervene and enforce these agreements. For real estate practitioners and developers, this ruling serves as a stern reminder that internal management disputes or changes in project specifications cannot be utilized to prejudice the vested statutory rights of certified occupants. By: Mr. Akash Jain, Associate Partner Mr. Divyang Salvi, Associate Ms. Diva Lathi, Associate
SEBI Update
REGULATORY UPDATE | SEBI ORDERS VARANIUM CLOUD TO RESTORE & DISGORGE FUNDS OVER IPO & RIGHT ISSUE FRAUD
The Securities and Exchange Board of India (“SEBI”) on 25 August 2025 passed a Final Order against Varanium Cloud Limited (“VCL”) and its key management for alleged fraudulent and misleading activities in connection with its Initial Public Offer (IPO), Rights Issue and subsequent disclosures. BACKGROUND The proceedings stemmed from SEBI’s preliminary examination pursuant to media reports and complaints regarding VCL’s financial statements and corporate announcements, which led to an Interim Order dated 10 May 2024 against VCL and its MD/Chairman, Harshwardhan Hanmant Sabale (Mr Sabale). VCL raised approximately Rs 40.39 crore through its IPO in September 2022 (primarily for Edge Data Centres and Edmission Digital Learning Centres) and proposed a further Rs. 48.45 crore through a Rights Issue in September 2023. SEBI examined the utilisation of issue proceeds, financial statements, Prospectus disclosures, corporate announcements, related-party transactions, and the role of directors, the CFO, the merchant banker and other intermediaries. SEBI’S FINDINGS SEBI found that VCL misrepresented its financial statements and prospectus by showing fictitious sales and purchases, and that its disclosures on utilisation of IPO proceeds (including the Statement of Deviation dated 17 November 2023) were incorrect and misleading. SEBI found that IPO and Rights Issue proceeds of Rs. 62.51 crore were diverted to related parties and other entities, including Rs. 32.73 crore transferred directly to Mr Sabale’s personal account. BM Traders (operated by Mr Raj Jagtani) received Rs. 19.66 crore in aggregate from the issue proceeds, of which Rs. 15.60 crore was transferred onwards; and that no adequate evidence of genuine business purpose was produced. SEBI found several business announcements by VCL to be false and unsubstantiated. SEBI also found that the Company also failed to support the substantial increase in reported revenues (including those of its US subsidiary) with invoices, contracts or employee details. Pending litigation was omitted from the Letter of Offer, and the Prospectus contained material omissions and misstatements. Liability was fastened on the Company, its MD, Executive Directors and CFO. SEBI found that the lead manager, First Overseas Capital Limited (FOCL), failed to exercise independent due diligence and did not disclose pending litigation. SEBI rejected FOCL’s defence that  it  could  rely  on  the  Company’s  representations  and  third-party  reports. Athos Capital Advisors Private Limited (ACAPL) and Mr Jinesh Mehta were held to have aided and abetted the misrepresentations; ACAPL received approximately Rs. 2.50 crore from VCL, and Mr Mehta admitted drafting portions of the Prospectus and assisting with fundraising. SEBI’S DIRECTIONS VCL was directed to bring back Rs. 62.51 crore (with 12% p.a. interest) within three months. Mr Sabale was directed to disgorge unlawful gains of Rs. 128.77 crore (with 12% p.a. simple interest) to the Investor Protection and Education Fund. VCL and Mr Sabale were debarred from the securities market for 7 years. ACAPL and Mr Jinesh Mehta were debarred for 2 years; Mr Raj Jagtani/BM Traders for 4 years; the Executive Directors and CFO (Mr Vinayak Jadhav, Mr Mukundan Raghavan and Mr Fahim Shaikh) for 1 year; and FOCL for 2 years (to run consecutively with an earlier debarment). Monetary penalties were also imposed, including Rs. 20.40 crore on Mr Sabale, Rs. 13 crore on VCL and Rs. 10.10 crore on Mr Raj Jagtani. Proceedings against the Company Secretary (Ms Hetal Somani) and a Non-Executive Director (Mr Kalpesh Acharekar) were disposed of without directions or penalty, the allegations against them being found unsustainable. MHCO COMMENT The order is significant for its treatment of misrepresentation in financial statements and public-issue disclosures, diversion of IPO and Rights Issue proceeds, and the accountability of directors, KMPs and intermediaries. It reiterates that a lead manager must conduct independent due diligence and cannot merely rely on the issuer’s representations or third-party reports. SEBI did not fasten liability on every director or officer; allegations against the Company Secretary and non-executive director were dropped for want of material. Overall, SEBI characterised the matter as a fraudulent scheme of raising public funds on misleading disclosures, followed by diversion of proceeds and creation of a false picture of the Company’s performance. The restoration, disgorgement, debarment and penalty directions reflect the seriousness with which the conduct was viewed. By: Mr. Bhushan Shah, Partner Mr. Abhishek Nair, Associate Ms. Sayali Kshirsagar, Associate
Rea Estate
BOMBAY HIGH COURT ALLOWS REFUND OF STAMP DUTY PAID ON CANCELLED DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
The Bombay High Court, vide judgment dated 20 August 2026 in Sai Innovation v. Joint District Registrar and Collector of Stamps, Pune City & Ors. (Writ Petition No. 7566 of 2016), has held that a Development Agreement which fails to achieve its intended purpose and is subsequently cancelled can qualify for refund of stamp duty under Section 47(c)(5) of the Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958 (“the Stamp Act”), and that such an agreement can avail the extended limitation period under the proviso to Section 48(1) where stamp duty has been calculated with reference to Article 25 of Schedule I. Background: Sai Innovation had entered into a Development Agreement (“said Agreement”) dated 15 April 2013 with the owners of land at Village Mauje Balewadi, Pune, for development of approximately 8,000 sq. metres of land and paid stamp duty under Article 25 read with Article 5 of Schedule I to the Stamp Act. The owners were unable to obtain sanction of the building plans within a reasonable time, and disputes subsequently arose between the parties. The said Agreement was therefore cancelled by a registered Deed of Cancellation (“said Deed”) dated 18 February 2014, registered on 24 February 2014, and the consideration received was returned. Sai Innovation thereafter applied on 7 April 2014 for refund of the stamp duty. The Respondent Nos 1&2 vide their orders dated 11 August 2014 and 6 December 2014 (“Impugned Orders”) respectively, rejected the refund application of the Petitioner, principally on the ground that the said Agreement was not a “conveyance” and therefore did not fall within the proviso to Section 48(1) of the Stamp Act. Issue: The Court dealt with the following issues: Whether the said Agreement had failed to achieve its intended purpose to attract Section 47(c)(5) of the Stamp Act; Whether a Development Agreement could avail the benefit of the proviso to Section 48(1), particularly where stamp duty was calculated as per Article 25 of Schedule I; Whether the reference to “actual, open possession” in Clause 13 of said Agreement be interpreted as transfer of possession to the developer, notwithstanding Clause 11 of the said Agreement which described the developer as a licensee; and Whether the Respondents could subsequently rely upon the alleged transfer of possession as a ground for rejecting the refund claim, when the refund claim had initially been rejected by the Impugned Orders on other grounds, and the issue of possession did not form part of the reasons recorded in those orders. Key Findings The Court, while differentiating between Section 47 and Section 48 of the Stamp Act, held that while Section 47 is the main provision that gives the right to a refund of stamp duty, Section 48 only deals with the time limit. In the present case, the proposed development under the said Agreement was never acted upon, and the parties later cancelled the said Agreement by the said Deed. As a result, the transaction had clearly failed to achieve its intended purpose under Section 47(c)(5) of the Stamp Act. The Court therefore said the refund claim had to be examined first under Section 47 and could not be turned down simply by pointing to the limitation period. On the question of possession, the Court held that Clause 13 of the said Agreement could not be read in isolation from Clause 11. Although Clause 13 referred to “actual, open possession”, Clause 11 expressly described the developer’s rights as those of “a licensee for development”. Reading the Agreement as a whole, the Court concluded that the developer was granted only a limited contractual licence to enter the property and undertake development activities, and that there was no transfer of legal or exclusive possession. The Court also noted that the absence of a separate possession receipt, by itself, did not establish that possession had been transferred. Held In light of the above reasoning, the Court allowed the writ petition and quashed the Impugned Orders passed by the Respondents. The Court held that the refund application was filed within the extended period prescribed under the proviso to Section 48(1) of the Stamp Act and, accordingly, rejected the Respondents’ objection that the claim was barred by the ordinary six-month limitation period. MHCO Comment Parties seeking refund of stamp duty on a cancelled Development Agreement should note that Section 47 governs the substantive entitlement to refund, while the proviso to Section 48(1) determines the applicable limitation period. Further, the legal character of a Development Agreement should be assessed by reading the same meaningfully and not in isolation from other clauses provided therein. By: Mr. Bhushan Shah, Partner Ms. Meeta Kadhi, Associate Partner Mr. Saptadip Nandi Chowdhury, Associate
LIFE AT MHCO
Need Help? Chat with us